CAFC vs Aveley – Report
Result: Aveley 2 – 1 Carshalton Athletic (HT 1 – 0)
Date: 24/10/26 KO: 15:00
Venue: Parkside, Aveley
Carshalton Athletic exited the FA Trophy on Saturday afternoon after falling to a 2-1 defeat against Aveley at Parkside.
Manager Steven Bates made one change to the side that lost to Wingate & Finchley on Tuesday evening, with Prince Kandolo replacing Ethan Kaiser in defence. There was also a place on the bench for new signing Seydil Toure, who joins the club as a centre-back after recently departing Walton & Hersham.
Carshalton got the game underway on a rainy afternoon in Essex, but it was the hosts who made the fastest start, opening the scoring in the eighth minute. Giovanni Palmer delivered a ball from the left-hand side that evaded everyone, including Ben Dudzinski, before nestling in the far corner to give Aveley a 1-0 lead.

It was a frustrating goal to concede, but the Robins were beginning to grow into the game. They won a free kick just outside the box, with Nathan Young-Coombes stepping up to take it. He went for goal, but saw his effort blocked by a defender. The ball then fell kindly to Matt Yates, whose effort was saved by George Miller. Just a minute later, Young-Coombes went close with a low effort, but his strike went just wide.
Young-Coombes then had a golden opportunity to equalise in the 28th minute. Matt Yates curled a brilliant through ball over the top for Young-Coombes, who raced through on goal. However, the former Brentford man was unable to take the chance, firing his shot wide.

The Robins went close again a few minutes later. Fabio Saraiva whipped a free kick into the penalty area from the left-hand side, and goalkeeper George Miller punched the ball clear, but only into the path of Chris Regis. The Robins midfielder struck a first-time effort at goal, but blazed his shot over the crossbar.
Aveley also created a few chances of their own before the break. The hosts won a corner on the left-hand side and delivered the ball to the back post. Captain Matt Johnson got his head to it, but could only direct his effort into the side netting. Just before half-time, Aveley nearly scored a second. A cross from the right-hand side took a wicked deflection and almost caught Dudzinski out, but the Robins’ number one was able to tip the ball away.

The referee blew for half-time, with the Robins trailing 1-0. Steven Bates’ side had created enough chances to at least be level, but they had been unable to take them and now had work to do to get back into the game.
The Robins started the second half on the front foot, with two of Carshalton’s newer signings linking up to create an opportunity. Andre Changunda did well on the left-hand side to cut the ball back to Jacob Safa. The Charlton loanee jinked past a defender, but fired his shot wide from close range. The Robins went close again shortly afterwards, as Nathan Young-Coombes cut the ball back to Tope Fadahunsi. However, the former Chatham forward couldn’t get his shot on target, firing wide.

The Robins were unable to convert their chances in the opening stages of the second half, and things got worse in the 52nd minute when Aveley doubled their advantage. The hosts won a corner on the left-hand side, which was delivered into the penalty area. Harry Critchley found himself unmarked and was able to head the ball into the bottom corner to make it 2-0.

The Robins had come back from two goals down in the previous round at Southall last month and weren’t ready to throw in the towel just yet. Young-Coombes dribbled into the box before firing an effort towards the bottom corner. Miller pushed the shot away, but only into the path of Tope Fadahunsi, who struck the rebound first time. Agonisingly, however, his effort hit the post before going out for a goal kick.

Carshalton had another glorious chance in the 78th minute. Nathan Young-Coombes drove down the left-hand side before cutting the ball back to Denzel Akyeampong on the edge of the box. The Robins full-back struck a first-time effort at goal, but couldn’t keep his shot down as it sailed over the crossbar.

Aveley were looking to kill the game off and brought on Anthony Jeffrey. The former Dulwich man was involved immediately, racing through on goal, but his shot was saved by Ben Dudzinski’s feet.
The referee signalled six minutes of stoppage time, and the Robins pulled a goal back in the fourth minute of added time. A free kick from the right-hand side was swung into the danger area, where substitute Seydil Toure rose highest to head the ball home and make it 2-1, setting up a frantic finish.

The Robins pushed for a late equaliser, but Aveley held on to secure a 2-1 victory and book their place in Monday’s second-round draw. After playing well but losing at Wingate & Finchley in midweek, The Robins will have a sense of déjà vu following a similar performance against Aveley, where they created numerous chances but were unable to convert them, ultimately ending up on the wrong side of the scoreline.

Commenting on X after the game, manager Steven Bates said: “Deserved more than we got today but credit to Aveley. We created enough chances to win two games but we must be better in both boxes. The boys worked their socks off and the disappointment of not turning this around for the unbelievable Carshalton Athletic fans was apparent.”
Up next, the Robins return to cup action on Tuesday evening, this time in the Surrey Senior Cup, as they travel to Step 5 side Knaphill.
LINEUP Aveley: Miller, Keto, Critchley, Armin, Palmer, Harvest, Napa, Ngandu, Johnson, Mohammed-Mariche, Bates
SUBS: Jeffrey, Kelly, Hibbert, Moralee, Okello
LINEUP Carshalton: Dudzinski, Akyeampong, Safa, Young-Coombes, Changunda, Regis, Saraiva, Kandolo, Fadahunsi, Yates, Jones
SUBS: Hechachena, Colwell, Toure, Koroma, Anderson
GOALS: Aveley: Palmer (9), Critchley (52)
GOALS: Carshalton: Toure (90+4)
Up Next
Date: Tuesday 27th October 2026
Opponents: Knaphill
Competition: Surrey Senior Cup 1st Round (Last 32)
KO: 7:45pm
Venue: Redding Way, Knaphill, Woking, GU21 2AY
Admissions: Adult £9, Concession £5, U16 £5
Tickets: Purchase Here or at the turnstiles





